Problem Analysis #8

64.46s
8,013 toks
Problem Statement

Let n=8n=8. Consider the family F\mathcal{F} of all linear subspaces C{0,1}8C\subseteq \{0,1\}^8 such that

  • dim(C)=4\dim(C)=4;

  • every codeword has even Hamming weight;

  • CC is self-orthogonal:

uv0(mod2)u,vC.\mathbf{u}\cdot \mathbf{v}\equiv 0\pmod 2 \quad \forall\,\mathbf{u},\mathbf{v}\in C.

What is F|\mathcal{F}|?

Ground Truth
135
Execution Trace
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] I'll compute the number of 4-dimensional subspaces of (\mathbb{F}_2^8) that are self-orthogonal (which automatically implies even weights), i.e., the number of binary self-dual ([8,4]) codes, by brute force enumeration using Python. I will:

  1. Enumerate all 4-dimensional subspaces via their unique RREF generator matrices.
  2. For each such subspace, check if it is self-orthogonal.
  3. Count how many satisfy this property.

First, I'll verify the Gaussian binomial (\binom{8}{4}_2) as the total number of 4-dim subspaces, then actually enumerate and test each subspace. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] import itertools import numpy as np

Helper: compute Gaussian binomial [n;k]_2 for verification

def gaussian_binomial_2(n, k): num = 1 den = 1 for i in range(k): num = (2*(n - i) - 1) den = (2*(k - i) - 1) return num // den

print("Gaussian [8;4]_2 =", gaussian_binomial_2(8,4))

Now enumerate all 4-dim subspaces via their unique RREF(4x8) generators.

We'll generate all 4x8 binary matrices in RREF with rank 4, by:

- choosing pivot columns (i1<i2<i3<i4)

- setting an identity on these pivots

- assigning arbitrary 4-bit columns to the remaining 4 positions

But not every such matrix is in RREF; we must enforce RREF conditions properly.

We'll instead generate all 4x8 binary matrices with rank 4, compute their RREF,

and store only distinct RREFs. However, that is 2^(32) possibilities, too big.

So instead, we carefully generate valid RREFs directly.

Conditions for RREF for 4x8 over GF(2):

1) Each row's first 1 (if any) is a pivot.

2) Pivot columns strictly increase from row to row.

3) In pivot column j, the pivot row has 1, and all other rows have 0.

4) All-zero rows are at the bottom (none here since rank 4).

A standard parametrization:

For a fixed ordered tuple of pivot columns p[0]<p[1]<p[2]<p[3],

every non-pivot column c is a 4-bit column vector v.

But RREF additionally requires: in each row i, entries before the pivot p[i]

in that row must be zero. This restricts some components of v to be 0

depending on whether column c is before or between pivots.

We'll construct columns from left to right, tracking allowed degrees of freedom.

def generate_rref_matrices_4x8(): n = 8 k = 4 # choose pivot positions for pivots in itertools.combinations(range(n), k): # Precompute, for each column index c, which row indices must be zero # because they are left of that row's pivot. # For row r, all columns < pivots[r] must be 0 in that row. zero_constraints = [[] for _ in range(n)] # zero_constraints[c] = list of rows that must be 0 at column c for c in range(n): for r in range(k): if c < pivots[r]: zero_constraints[c].append(r) # Now we construct the matrix column by column. # We know pivot columns: column pivots[r] is e_r (unit vector in row r). # Non-pivot columns: bits are free except for forced zeros in zero_constraints. # We'll iterate over all assignments to free bits across the 4 non-pivot columns. non_pivot_cols = [c for c in range(n) if c not in pivots] # For each non-pivot column, number of free bits = 4 - (#constrained zeros). # To enumerate all matrices, we can just iterate over all combinations of bits # for all non-pivot columns combined. free_bits_per_col = [4 - len(zero_constraints[c]) for c in non_pivot_cols] total_free_bits = sum(free_bits_per_col) # If total_free_bits is large, this might be big, but with n=8,k=4 it's manageable. # We'll encode all free bits in a single integer from 0..2^total_free_bits-1 for mask in range(1 << total_free_bits): M = np.zeros((k, n), dtype=int) # set pivot columns to identity for r, c in enumerate(pivots): M[r, c] = 1 # fill non-pivot columns bit_index = 0 for c in non_pivot_cols: # prepare a column vector of length k col = [0]*k # enforce zero constraints constrained_rows = set(zero_constraints[c]) free_rows = [r for r in range(k) if r not in constrained_rows] for r in free_rows: # get next bit from mask bit = (mask >> bit_index) & 1 bit_index += 1 col[r] = bit # place the column for r in range(k): M[r, c] = col[r] # M is a candidate RREF by construction, with full rank 4. yield M

Test the generator: count how many distinct RREF row spaces we get,

and verify it matches the Gaussian binomial

seen = set() count = 0 for M in generate_rref_matrices_4x8(): # Row space over GF(2) can be represented by a tuple of sorted row-vectors (as ints) rows = [int("".join(str(bit) for bit in row), 2) for row in M] # To be safe, compute RREF via simple Gaussian elimination to ensure canonical form # but since constructed as RREF, we accept as is. We'll still sort rows for hashing. rows_sorted = tuple(sorted(rows)) if rows_sorted not in seen: seen.add(rows_sorted) count += 1

print("Number of distinct 4-dim subspaces (by our RREF generation):", count)

Now, among these subspaces, count those that are self-orthogonal:

def is_self_orthogonal(M): # M: 4x8 generator matrix rows spanning C # compute Gram matrix G = M M^T over GF(2); must be zero for self-orthogonal G = (M @ M.T) % 2 return np.all(G == 0)

self_orth_count = 0 for M in generate_rref_matrices_4x8(): if is_self_orthogonal(M): # Count each subspace once by its row space (RREF is unique per subspace) self_orth_count += 1

print("Number of self-orthogonal 4-dim subspaces:", self_orth_count) [/PYTHON]

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] Gaussian [8;4]_2 = 200787 Number of distinct 4-dim subspaces (by our RREF generation): 200787 Number of self-orthogonal 4-dim subspaces: 135 [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] The Python enumeration confirms that there are exactly 135 distinct 4-dimensional self-orthogonal binary subspaces of ({0,1}^8) satisfying the given conditions. This is the required size of (\mathcal{F}). [ |\mathcal{F}| = 135 ] [/THOUGHT] \boxed{135}

Final Model Output
135

Comparative Analysis (P8) (Average across runs)

Avg Time Taken

Claude-Opus-4.5
709.8
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
378.2
Deepseek-V3.2
359.2
Grok-4.1-fast
123.9
GPT-5.1 (high)
62.6

Avg Token Usage

Grok-4.1-fast
16430.7
Deepseek-V3.2
14331.3
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
10425.3
Claude-Opus-4.5
8337.7
GPT-5.1 (high)
6573.7