Problem Analysis #47

62.65s
22,479 toks
Problem Statement

Consider the tetrahedron ABCDABCD with AB=CD=4\overline{AB} = \overline{CD} = 4 and BC=BD=25\overline{BC} = \overline{BD} = 2\sqrt{5}. Let HH be the foot of the perpendicular from AA to line CDCD. Suppose that the planes ABHABH and BCDBCD are perpendicular to each other and that AH=4\overline{AH} = 4. Let GG be the centroid of triangle ABHABH, and let SS be the sphere with center GG tangent to the plane ACDACD. Let TT be the locus of all points PP on SS such that APG=π2\angle APG = \dfrac{\pi}{2}. Find the area of the orthogonal projection of TT onto the plane ABCABC. [4 points]\subsection*{Numerical answer}If Area = πk\frac{\pi}{k}, compute kk.

Ground Truth
4
Execution Trace
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] Let me work through this problem step by step.

First, I need to set up coordinates for the tetrahedron ABCD with the given constraints:

  • AB = CD = 4
  • BC = BD = 2√5
  • H is the foot of perpendicular from A to line CD
  • AH = 4
  • Planes ABH and BCD are perpendicular

Let me place the coordinate system strategically. Since H is on line CD and AH ⊥ CD, I'll work with coordinates.

Let me start by setting up the geometry and finding all the points. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] import numpy as np from scipy.optimize import fsolve import sympy as sp from sympy import sqrt, Rational, pi, symbols, solve, simplify, Matrix

Let's set up coordinates

Place H at origin, CD along x-axis

Since AH ⊥ CD and AH = 4, A is at distance 4 from H perpendicular to CD

Let H = (0, 0, 0)

CD is along x-axis, so C = (-c, 0, 0) and D = (d, 0, 0) for some c, d > 0

CD = 4 means c + d = 4

A is perpendicular to CD from H, so A is in the yz-plane

Let A = (0, a_y, a_z) with a_y^2 + a_z^2 = 16 (since AH = 4)

Plane ABH contains A, B, H

Plane BCD contains B, C, D

These planes are perpendicular

Let's use symbolic computation

c, d, a_y, a_z = symbols('c d a_y a_z', real=True, positive=True) b_x, b_y, b_z = symbols('b_x b_y b_z', real=True)

H at origin

H = Matrix([0, 0, 0])

C and D on x-axis

C = Matrix([-c, 0, 0]) D = Matrix([d, 0, 0])

A perpendicular to x-axis from H

A = Matrix([0, a_y, a_z])

B general position

B = Matrix([b_x, b_y, b_z])

Constraints:

1. CD = 4: c + d = 4

2. AH = 4: a_y^2 + a_z^2 = 16

3. AB = 4: b_x^2 + (b_y - a_y)^2 + (b_z - a_z)^2 = 16

4. BC = 2√5: (b_x + c)^2 + b_y^2 + b_z^2 = 20

5. BD = 2√5: (b_x - d)^2 + b_y^2 + b_z^2 = 20

From 4 and 5: (b_x + c)^2 = (b_x - d)^2

=> b_x^2 + 2b_xc + c^2 = b_x^2 - 2b_xd + d^2

=> 2b_x(c + d) = d^2 - c^2 = (d-c)(d+c)

=> 2b_x4 = (d-c)*4

=> b_x = (d-c)/2

Plane BCD: normal vector is (B-C) × (D-C)

BC_vec = B - C DC_vec = D - C

Normal to BCD

n_BCD = BC_vec.cross(DC_vec) print("Normal to BCD (symbolic):", n_BCD)

Plane ABH: contains A, B, H

Vectors in plane: A-H = A, B-H = B

n_ABH = A.cross(B) print("Normal to ABH (symbolic):", n_ABH) [/PYTHON]

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] Normal to BCD (symbolic): Matrix([[0], [b_z*(c + d)], [-b_y*(c + d)]]) Normal to ABH (symbolic): Matrix([[a_y*b_z - a_z*b_y], [a_z*b_x], [-a_y*b_x]]) [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] Let me continue the calculation to find all the coordinates and then compute the final answer. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] import numpy as np from sympy import *

Let's set up with specific coordinates

H at origin, CD along x-axis

From constraint c + d = 4 and b_x = (d-c)/2

Planes ABH and BCD perpendicular means their normals are perpendicular

n_BCD = (0, b_z*(c+d), -b_y*(c+d)) = (0, 4b_z, -4b_y)

n_ABH = (a_yb_z - a_zb_y, a_zb_x, -a_yb_x)

n_BCD · n_ABH = 0

0 + 4b_za_zb_x + 4b_ya_yb_x = 0

4b_x(a_zb_z + a_yb_y) = 0

Either b_x = 0 or a_zb_z + a_yb_y = 0

Let's try b_x = 0 first (meaning d = c = 2)

Then C = (-2, 0, 0), D = (2, 0, 0)

With b_x = 0:

BC = 2√5: c^2 + b_y^2 + b_z^2 = 20 => 4 + b_y^2 + b_z^2 = 20 => b_y^2 + b_z^2 = 16

AB = 4: (b_y - a_y)^2 + (b_z - a_z)^2 = 16

AH = 4: a_y^2 + a_z^2 = 16

Let's parameterize: a_y = 4cos(θ), a_z = 4sin(θ)

b_y = 4cos(φ), b_z = 4sin(φ)

AB^2 = (4cos(φ) - 4cos(θ))^2 + (4sin(φ) - 4sin(θ))^2 = 16

= 16*(cos(φ) - cos(θ))^2 + 16*(sin(φ) - sin(θ))^2 = 16

= 16*(cos²φ - 2*cos(φ)cos(θ) + cos²θ + sin²φ - 2sin(φ)*sin(θ) + sin²θ) = 16

= 16*(2 - 2*cos(φ-θ)) = 16

=> 2 - 2*cos(φ-θ) = 1

=> cos(φ-θ) = 1/2

=> φ - θ = ±π/3

Let's take θ = 0 (A in y-direction): A = (0, 4, 0)

Then φ = π/3: B = (0, 4cos(π/3), 4sin(π/3)) = (0, 2, 2√3)

Let me verify all constraints

A = np.array([0, 4, 0]) B = np.array([0, 2, 2*np.sqrt(3)]) C = np.array([-2, 0, 0]) D = np.array([2, 0, 0]) H = np.array([0, 0, 0])

print("AB =", np.linalg.norm(A - B)) print("CD =", np.linalg.norm(C - D)) print("BC =", np.linalg.norm(B - C)) print("BD =", np.linalg.norm(B - D)) print("AH =", np.linalg.norm(A - H))

Check H is foot of perpendicular from A to CD

CD is along x-axis, A = (0, 4, 0), so perpendicular foot is (0, 0, 0) = H ✓

Check planes ABH and BCD are perpendicular

Normal to BCD: BC × BD

BC = C - B BD = D - B n_BCD = np.cross(BC, BD) print("n_BCD =", n_BCD)

Normal to ABH: HA × HB

HA = A - H HB = B - H n_ABH = np.cross(HA, HB) print("n_ABH =", n_ABH)

Check perpendicularity

dot_product = np.dot(n_BCD, n_ABH) print("n_BCD · n_ABH =", dot_product) [/PYTHON]

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] AB = 3.9999999999999996 CD = 4.0 BC = 4.47213595499958 BD = 4.47213595499958 AH = 4.0 n_BCD = [ 0. -13.85640646 8. ] n_ABH = [13.85640646 0. 0. ] n_BCD · n_ABH = 0.0 [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] The coordinates are verified. Now I need to continue with finding G (centroid of triangle ABH), the sphere S, the locus T, and finally the projection onto plane ABC. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] import numpy as np from numpy.linalg import norm

Verified coordinates

A = np.array([0, 4, 0]) B = np.array([0, 2, 2*np.sqrt(3)]) C = np.array([-2, 0, 0]) D = np.array([2, 0, 0]) H = np.array([0, 0, 0])

G = centroid of triangle ABH

G = (A + B + H) / 3 print("G =", G)

Sphere S has center G and is tangent to plane ACD

Find equation of plane ACD

Vectors in plane: AC = C - A, AD = D - A

AC = C - A AD = D - A n_ACD = np.cross(AC, AD) print("Normal to ACD:", n_ACD) n_ACD_unit = n_ACD / norm(n_ACD) print("Unit normal to ACD:", n_ACD_unit)

Distance from G to plane ACD

Plane through A with normal n: n · (P - A) = 0

Distance = |n · (G - A)| / |n|

dist_G_to_ACD = abs(np.dot(n_ACD, G - A)) / norm(n_ACD) print("Distance from G to plane ACD (radius of S):", dist_G_to_ACD)

r_S = dist_G_to_ACD

T is locus of points P on S such that angle APG = π/2

This means AP ⊥ PG, so P lies on sphere with diameter AG

T = intersection of sphere S (center G, radius r_S) with sphere with diameter AG

Sphere with diameter AG has center at midpoint of AG and radius |AG|/2

M = (A + G) / 2 r_AG = norm(A - G) / 2 print("Center of sphere with diameter AG:", M) print("Radius of sphere with diameter AG:", r_AG)

T is the intersection of two spheres

Sphere 1: center G, radius r_S

Sphere 2: center M, radius r_AG

Distance between centers

d_GM = norm(G - M) print("Distance between G and M:", d_GM)

The intersection is a circle. Let's find its radius.

Using formula for intersection of two spheres

If spheres have centers C1, C2, radii r1, r2, distance d between centers

The intersection circle has radius r = sqrt(r1^2 - h^2) where h is distance from C1 to plane of circle

h = (d^2 + r1^2 - r2^2) / (2d)

d = d_GM r1 = r_S r2 = r_AG

h = (d2 + r12 - r2**2) / (2*d) print("h (distance from G to plane of T):", h)

r_T = np.sqrt(r12 - h2) print("Radius of circle T:", r_T)

Now find the plane of T

The plane of T is perpendicular to line GM and passes through point G + h*(M-G)/|M-G|

GM_unit = (M - G) / norm(M - G) center_T = G + h * GM_unit print("Center of circle T:", center_T)

Normal to plane of T is GM_unit

normal_T = GM_unit print("Normal to plane of T:", normal_T) [/PYTHON]

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] G = [0. 2. 1.15470054] Normal to ACD: [ 0 0 16] Unit normal to ACD: [0. 0. 1.] Distance from G to plane ACD (radius of S): 1.1547005383792515 Center of sphere with diameter AG: [0. 3. 0.57735027] Radius of sphere with diameter AG: 1.1547005383792515 Distance between G and M: 1.1547005383792515 h (distance from G to plane of T): 0.5773502691896257 Radius of circle T: 1.0 Center of circle T: [0. 2.5 0.8660254] Normal to plane of T: [ 0. 0.8660254 -0.5 ] [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] Now I need to find the orthogonal projection of circle T onto plane ABC, and compute its area. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] import numpy as np from numpy.linalg import norm

Circle T has:

- Center: (0, 2.5, √3/2)

- Radius: 1

- Normal: (0, √3/2, -1/2)

Plane ABC: find its equation

A = np.array([0, 4, 0]) B = np.array([0, 2, 2*np.sqrt(3)]) C = np.array([-2, 0, 0])

AB = B - A AC = C - A n_ABC = np.cross(AB, AC) print("Normal to ABC:", n_ABC) n_ABC_unit = n_ABC / norm(n_ABC) print("Unit normal to ABC:", n_ABC_unit)

Normal to plane of T

normal_T = np.array([0, np.sqrt(3)/2, -0.5]) normal_T_unit = normal_T / norm(normal_T) print("Unit normal to T:", normal_T_unit)

When projecting a circle onto a plane, the projection is an ellipse

The area of projection = area of circle * |cos(θ)|

where θ is the angle between the plane of the circle and the target plane

cos(θ) = |n_T · n_ABC| (dot product of unit normals)

cos_theta = abs(np.dot(normal_T_unit, n_ABC_unit)) print("cos(theta):", cos_theta)

Area of circle T

area_T = np.pi * 1**2 print("Area of circle T:", area_T)

Area of projection

area_projection = area_T * cos_theta print("Area of projection:", area_projection)

Express as π/k

area_projection = π * cos_theta = π/k

So k = 1/cos_theta

k = 1 / cos_theta print("k =", k)

Let's compute this more precisely with sympy

import sympy as sp from sympy import sqrt, pi, Rational, simplify, cos, acos

Exact values

A_s = sp.Matrix([0, 4, 0]) B_s = sp.Matrix([0, 2, 2*sqrt(3)]) C_s = sp.Matrix([-2, 0, 0])

AB_s = B_s - A_s AC_s = C_s - A_s n_ABC_s = AB_s.cross(AC_s) print("Exact normal to ABC:", n_ABC_s)

Normal to T: (0, √3/2, -1/2) or equivalently (0, √3, -1)

n_T_s = sp.Matrix([0, sqrt(3), -1])

Compute dot product and magnitudes

dot = n_ABC_s.dot(n_T_s) mag_ABC = sp.sqrt(n_ABC_s.dot(n_ABC_s)) mag_T = sp.sqrt(n_T_s.dot(n_T_s))

cos_theta_exact = sp.Abs(dot) / (mag_ABC * mag_T) cos_theta_exact = simplify(cos_theta_exact) print("Exact cos(theta):", cos_theta_exact)

Area = π * r^2 * cos(theta) = π * 1 * cos(theta)

area_exact = pi * cos_theta_exact print("Exact area:", simplify(area_exact))

k = 1/cos(theta)

k_exact = 1 / cos_theta_exact print("Exact k:", simplify(k_exact)) [/PYTHON]

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] Normal to ABC: [13.85640646 -6.92820323 -4. ] Unit normal to ABC: [ 0.8660254 -0.4330127 -0.25 ] Unit normal to T: [ 0. 0.8660254 -0.5 ] cos(theta): 0.25 Area of circle T: 3.141592653589793 Area of projection: 0.7853981633974483 k = 4.0 Exact normal to ABC: Matrix([[8*sqrt(3)], [-4*sqrt(3)], [-4]]) Exact cos(theta): 1/4 Exact area: pi/4 Exact k: 4 [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] The calculation shows that the area of the orthogonal projection of T onto plane ABC is π/4. Therefore, k = 4. [/THOUGHT]

\boxed{4}

Final Model Output
4

Comparative Analysis (P47) (Average across runs)

Avg Time Taken

Deepseek-V3.2
1339.3
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
227.0
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
197.5
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
88.5
GPT-5.1 (high)
77.0
Claude-Opus-4.5
62.7
Grok-4.1-fast
45.4
A.X-4.0 (72B)
24.3
HCX-007(high)
13.4
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
6.9

Avg Token Usage

Deepseek-V3.2
168251.0
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
45158.0
Claude-Opus-4.5
22479.0
Grok-4.1-fast
12799.0
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
11892.0
GPT-5.1 (high)
9482.0
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
4517.0
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
3060.0
A.X-4.0 (72B)
2321.0
HCX-007(high)
1815.0