Problem Analysis #21

90.25s
10,461 toks
Problem Statement

\text{Let } P_1(1+\cos t,; \sin t)\text{ be a point moving on the circle with center } (1,0)\text{ and radius } 1,]and P2(2cosθ(t),  2sinθ(t)) be a point moving on the circle with center (0,0) and radius 2.\text{and }P_2(2\cos\theta(t),\; 2\sin\theta(t))\text{ be a point moving on the circle with center } (0,0)\text{ and radius } 2.Both points start at the intersection point (2,0)(2,0) of the two circlesand move counterclockwise along their respective circles.Assume that their speeds satisfyP1(t):P2(t)=1:4,(0t2π).|P_1'(t)| : |P_2'(t)| = 1 : 4,\qquad (0 \le t \le 2\pi).Let t=t0t = t_0 be the time when the distance between P1P_1 and P2P_2 is maximized.At this moment, the following expression:sint2sinθ(t)    (1+cost)2cosθ(t)=pq,\sin t \cdot 2\sin\theta(t)\;-\;(1+\cos t)\cdot 2\cos\theta(t)=\frac{p}{q},where pp and qq are relatively prime positive integers.Find the value of p+qp + q.oindent

Ground Truth
141
Execution Trace
Reasoning Process

The problem asks us to find the value of p+qp+q where p/qp/q is the value of a specific expression at the time t0t_0 when the distance between two moving points P1P_1 and P2P_2 is maximized.

First, let's determine the positions of P1P_1 and P2P_2. P1P_1 moves on a circle with center (1,0)(1,0) and radius 1. P1(t)=(1+cost,sint)P_1(t) = (1+\cos t, \sin t). P1(t)=(sint,cost)P_1'(t) = (-\sin t, \cos t), so speed P1(t)=1|P_1'(t)| = 1.

P2P_2 moves on a circle with center (0,0)(0,0) and radius 2. P2(t)=(2cosθ(t),2sinθ(t))P_2(t) = (2\cos\theta(t), 2\sin\theta(t)). Speed P2(t)=2θ(t)|P_2'(t)| = 2|\theta'(t)|. Given the ratio of speeds is 1:41:4, we have 1:2θ(t)=1:41 : 2|\theta'(t)| = 1:4, which implies θ(t)=2|\theta'(t)| = 2. Since the motion is counterclockwise, θ(t)=2\theta'(t) = 2. With the starting point (2,0)(2,0) at t=0t=0, we have θ(0)=0\theta(0)=0, so θ(t)=2t\theta(t) = 2t. Thus, P2(t)=(2cos(2t),2sin(2t))P_2(t) = (2\cos(2t), 2\sin(2t)).

Next, we find the time t0t_0 that maximizes the distance between P1P_1 and P2P_2. Let D2(t)D^2(t) be the squared distance. D2(t)=(1+cost2cos2t)2+(sint2sin2t)2D^2(t) = (1+\cos t - 2\cos 2t)^2 + (\sin t - 2\sin 2t)^2. Expanding this, we get: D2(t)=62cost4cos2tD^2(t) = 6 - 2\cos t - 4\cos 2t. To maximize distance, we minimize f(t)=2cost+4cos2tf(t) = 2\cos t + 4\cos 2t. Let x=costx = \cos t. Then cos2t=2x21\cos 2t = 2x^2 - 1. We minimize h(x)=2x+4(2x21)=8x2+2x4h(x) = 2x + 4(2x^2 - 1) = 8x^2 + 2x - 4 for x[1,1]x \in [-1, 1]. The minimum occurs at x=2/(28)=1/8x = -2/(2*8) = -1/8. So at t=t0t=t_0, cost0=1/8\cos t_0 = -1/8.

Finally, we evaluate the given expression at t0t_0: Expression =sint2sin(2t)(1+cost)2cos(2t)= \sin t \cdot 2\sin(2t) - (1+\cos t) \cdot 2\cos(2t). Using trigonometric identities, this simplifies to 2cos3t2cos2t-2\cos 3t - 2\cos 2t. In terms of x=costx = \cos t, this is 8x34x2+6x+2-8x^3 - 4x^2 + 6x + 2. Substituting x=1/8x = -1/8, we get the value 77/6477/64.

Thus p=77,q=64p=77, q=64. They are relatively prime. p+q=77+64=141p+q = 77+64 = 141.

[PYTHON] import sympy from sympy import symbols, cos, sin, diff, solve, simplify, Rational

t = symbols('t')

Define positions

x1 = 1 + cos(t) y1 = sin(t) x2 = 2 * cos(2t) y2 = 2 * sin(2t)

Squared distance

dist_sq = (x1 - x2)**2 + (y1 - y2)**2 dist_sq = simplify(dist_sq) print(f"Squared distance simplified: {dist_sq}")

To maximize distance, we minimize the negative of it, or just find critical points

Let's differentiate with respect to t

deriv = diff(dist_sq, t)

We want to solve deriv = 0

The expression involves sin(t) and sin(2t) etc.

Let's substitute cos(t) = x to find the algebraic minimum

x = symbols('x')

dist_sq in terms of x

From manual derivation: 6 - 2cos(t) - 4cos(2t)

cos(2t) = 2x^2 - 1

dist_x = 6 - 2x - 4(2*x**2 - 1) print(f"Distance squared in terms of x=cos(t): {dist_x}")

Find critical points for x in [-1, 1]

deriv_x = diff(dist_x, x) crit_points = solve(deriv_x, x) print(f"Critical points for x: {crit_points}")

Check which maximizes the distance

max_dist = -1 best_x = None for cp in crit_points: val = dist_x.subs(x, cp) if val > max_dist: max_dist = val best_x = cp

Check endpoints

for ep in [-1, 1]: val = dist_x.subs(x, ep) if val > max_dist: max_dist = val best_x = ep

print(f"x that maximizes distance: {best_x}")

Calculate the target expression at best_x

Expression: sin(t)*2sin(2t) - (1+cos(t))*2cos(2t)

Simplify this expression to terms of cos(t)

expr = sin(t) * 2 * sin(2t) - (1 + cos(t)) * 2 * cos(2t) expr_simplified = simplify(expr) print(f"Target expression simplified: {expr_simplified}")

Convert to polynomial in x

expr_simplified should be -2cos(2t) - 2cos(3t)

cos(2t) = 2x^2 - 1

cos(3t) = 4x^3 - 3x

poly_x = -2*(2x**2 - 1) - 2(4x**3 - 3x) print(f"Polynomial in x: {poly_x}")

final_val = poly_x.subs(x, best_x) print(f"Final value: {final_val}") [/PYTHON] [THOUGHT] The Python code confirmed the manual derivation. The squared distance is 108cos(t)22cos(t)10 - 8\cos(t)^2 - 2\cos(t). Wait, the Python output says 10 - 8*cos(t)**2 - 2*cos(t). My manual derivation was 62cost4cos2t=62cost4(2cos2t1)=62cost8cos2t+4=102cost8cos2t6 - 2\cos t - 4\cos 2t = 6 - 2\cos t - 4(2\cos^2 t - 1) = 6 - 2\cos t - 8\cos^2 t + 4 = 10 - 2\cos t - 8\cos^2 t. This matches the Python output. The critical point for x=costx = \cos t is found by maximizing 102x8x210 - 2x - 8x^2. Derivative is 216x=0    x=1/8-2 - 16x = 0 \implies x = -1/8. This matches. The target expression simplified to 2cos(2t)2cos(3t)-2\cos(2t) - 2\cos(3t). In terms of xx, this is 8x34x2+6x+2-8x^3 - 4x^2 + 6x + 2. Substituting x=1/8x = -1/8: Result is 77/6477/64. p=77,q=64p=77, q=64. p+q=141p+q = 141. The integers are relatively prime.

Final check of the question details:

  • P1P_1 center (1,0)(1,0), radius 1. Correct.
  • P2P_2 center (0,0)(0,0), radius 2. Correct.
  • Start at (2,0)(2,0). Correct.
  • Counterclockwise. Correct.
  • Speed ratio 1:41:4. Correct.
  • Expression: sint2sinθ(t)(1+cost)2cosθ(t)\sin t \cdot 2\sin\theta(t) - (1+\cos t)\cdot 2\cos\theta(t). Correct.
  • p,qp, q relatively prime positive integers. 77/6477/64 is positive. gcd(77,64)=1gcd(77, 64) = 1. Correct.

The value is 77/6477/64. p+q=77+64=141p+q = 77+64 = 141. [/THOUGHT]

\boxed{141}

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] Squared distance simplified: 8*sin(t)**2 - 2*cos(t) + 2 Distance squared in terms of x=cos(t): -8*x**2 - 2*x + 10 Critical points for x: [-1/8] x that maximizes distance: -1/8 Target expression simplified: -2*cos(2*t) - 2*cos(3*t) Polynomial in x: -8*x**3 - 4*x**2 + 6*x + 2 Final value: 77/64 [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

The value of the expression is 7764\frac{77}{64}. Thus p=77p=77 and q=64q=64. The sum p+q=77+64=141p+q = 77+64 = 141.

\boxed{141}

Final Model Output
141

Comparative Analysis (P21) (Average across runs)

Avg Time Taken

Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
93.9
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
90.3
GPT-5.1 (high)
73.6
Deepseek-V3.2
67.4
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
56.5
Grok-4.1-fast
41.6
HCX-007(high)
35.9
A.X-4.0 (72B)
32.7
Claude-Opus-4.5
28.3
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
9.6

Avg Token Usage

GPT-5.1 (high)
12127.0
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
10461.0
Grok-4.1-fast
10394.0
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
9571.0
Deepseek-V3.2
5739.0
A.X-4.0 (72B)
5617.0
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
5381.0
Claude-Opus-4.5
5284.0
HCX-007(high)
4768.0
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
3110.0