Problem Analysis #47

77.00s
9,482 toks
Problem Statement

Consider the tetrahedron ABCDABCD with AB=CD=4\overline{AB} = \overline{CD} = 4 and BC=BD=25\overline{BC} = \overline{BD} = 2\sqrt{5}. Let HH be the foot of the perpendicular from AA to line CDCD. Suppose that the planes ABHABH and BCDBCD are perpendicular to each other and that AH=4\overline{AH} = 4. Let GG be the centroid of triangle ABHABH, and let SS be the sphere with center GG tangent to the plane ACDACD. Let TT be the locus of all points PP on SS such that APG=π2\angle APG = \dfrac{\pi}{2}. Find the area of the orthogonal projection of TT onto the plane ABCABC. [4 points]\subsection*{Numerical answer}If Area = πk\frac{\pi}{k}, compute kk.

Ground Truth
4
Execution Trace
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] I'll use Python to:

  1. Solve for coordinates of B satisfying length and perpendicular-plane constraints (with A=(0,0,4), H=(0,0,0), C=(-2,0,0), D=(2,0,0)).
  2. Compute centroid G of triangle ABH.
  3. Find the plane ACD equation; S is sphere centered at G tangent to plane ACD, so its radius is distance from G to that plane.
  4. Describe the locus T: intersection of sphere S with sphere defined by right-angle condition ∠APG = 90°, i.e. (A−P)·(G−P)=0.
  5. Verify that this locus is a circle, find its center and radius in 3D.
  6. Find area of orthogonal projection of this circle onto plane ABC. For a circle with normal n, projected onto plane with normal m, area scales by |n·m|/|n|. So area_proj = area_circle * |n_T · n_ABC|.
  7. Get numeric value, express as π/k, then output k.

Now I'll implement this step-by-step in Python. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] import sympy as sp

Define symbols

y = sp.symbols('y', real=True)

Fixed points

A = sp.Matrix([0,0,4]) H = sp.Matrix([0,0,0]) C = sp.Matrix([-2,0,0]) D = sp.Matrix([2,0,0])

From earlier reasoning: B = (0, y, z) with z=2, y^2=12

z_val = 2 y_val1 = 2sp.sqrt(3) y_val2 = -2sp.sqrt(3)

B1 = sp.Matrix([0, y_val1, z_val]) B2 = sp.Matrix([0, y_val2, z_val])

def check_perpendicular_planes(B): # plane ABH: through A,B,H; normal n1 = (A-H) x (B-H) n1 = (A-H).cross(B-H) # plane BCD: through B,C,D; normal n2 = (C-B) x (D-B) n2 = (C-B).cross(D-B) return sp.simplify(n1.dot(n2)), n1, n2

dot1, n1_1, n2_1 = check_perpendicular_planes(B1) dot2, n1_2, n2_2 = check_perpendicular_planes(B2)

print("dot products for perpendicularity (should be 0):", sp.simplify(dot1), sp.simplify(dot2))

Choose B = B1

B = B1 print("B:", B)

Centroid G of triangle ABH: average of A,B,H

G = (A + B + H)/3 print("G:", sp.simplify(G))

Plane ACD: find its normal

n_ACD = (C-A).cross(D-A) print("n_ACD (unnormalized):", sp.simplify(n_ACD))

Distance from G to plane ACD gives radius R of sphere S centered at G tangent to plane ACD

Plane ACD equation: n_ACD · (X - A) = 0

X = sp.Matrix(sp.symbols('x y z', real=True))

distance formula: |n·(G-A)| / |n|

num = abs(n_ACD.dot(G-A)) den = sp.sqrt(n_ACD.dot(n_ACD)) R = sp.simplify(num/den) print("Radius R of sphere S:", R)

Sphere S: center G, radius R

Locus condition: angle APG = 90° => (A-P)·(G-P) = 0

x,y,z = sp.symbols('x y z', real=True) P = sp.Matrix([x,y,z])

eq_sphere = sp.simplify((P-G).dot(P-G) - R**2) eq_right = sp.simplify((A-P).dot(G-P))

print("Sphere S equation (symbolic, =0):", eq_sphere) print("Right angle condition (symbolic, =0):", eq_right)

Solve for the circle: intersection of two spheres

We'll complete the square algebraically by subtracting the two equations suitably.

eq_sphere = P·P - 2 G·P + G·G - R^2 = 0

eq_right = P·P - (A+G)·P + A·G = 0

Subtract eq_right from eq_sphere to get linear equation in P representing plane of the circle.

PdotP = x2 + y2 + z2 eq1 = sp.expand(PdotP - 2*(G.dot(P)) + (G.dot(G) - R2)) eq2 = sp.expand(PdotP - (A+G).dot(P) + (A.dot(G))) plane_circle = sp.simplify(eq1 - eq2) # =0 print("Plane of circle T (equation =0):", plane_circle)

Simplify plane equation to normal form n_T · X + d = 0

plane_circle_simplified = sp.factor(plane_circle) print("Plane circle simplified:", plane_circle_simplified)

We'll extract coefficients of x,y,z and constant

coeff_x = sp.simplify(sp.diff(plane_circle_simplified, x)) coeff_y = sp.simplify(sp.diff(plane_circle_simplified, y)) coeff_z = sp.simplify(sp.diff(plane_circle_simplified, z))

print("coefficients (pre-normalization):", coeff_x, coeff_y, coeff_z)

Actually need to account that expression is linear: ax + by + c*z + d.

a, b, c = coeff_x, coeff_y, coeff_z d = sp.simplify(plane_circle_simplified.subs({x:0,y:0,z:0})) n_T = sp.Matrix([a,b,c]) print("n_T:", sp.simplify(n_T), "d:", d)

Now find center of circle T: intersection point of its plane with the line joining centers of the two spheres.

General fact: intersection circle of two spheres lies in plane perpendicular to line of centers;

Center of circle lies on that line. So parametrize line through G (center of S) and some center C2 of second sphere.

Find center C2 and radius of second sphere for eq_right.

We know form: P·P - (A+G)·P + A·G = 0

Compare with P·P - 2 C2·P + (C2·C2 - r2^2) = 0

C2 = (A+G)/2 r2_sq = C2.dot(C2) - A.dot(G) print("C2:", sp.simplify(C2)) print("r2^2:", sp.simplify(r2_sq))

Parametric line L(t) = G + t*(C2 - G)

t = sp.symbols('t', real=True) L = G + t*(C2 - G)

Plug into plane equation for circle (plane_circle_simplified=0) to solve for t to get center M of circle

plane_L = sp.simplify(plane_circle_simplified.subs({x:L[0], y:L[1], z:L[2]})) t_sol = sp.solve(sp.Eq(plane_L, 0), t) print("t solution(s):", t_sol)

t0 = sp.simplify(t_sol[0]) M = sp.simplify(L.subs(t, t0)) print("Center M of circle T:", M)

Radius of circle T: distance from M to intersection with sphere S along direction in plane.

Use that M lies in plane of circle; pick an orthonormal basis in that plane and compute radius via constraint equations.

Alternatively, use formula for intersection radius:

If two spheres with centers O1,O2 and radii R1,R2, and d=|O1O2|,

radius^2 = R1^2 - a^2 where a = distance from O1 to circle center along line of centers = (R1^2 - R2^2 + d^2)/(2d)

G_point = G O1 = G_point O2 = C2 R1_sq = R**2 R2_sq = r2_sq d_vec = O2 - O1 d_len = sp.sqrt(sp.simplify(d_vec.dot(d_vec))) print("d_len between centers:", sp.simplify(d_len))

a = sp.simplify((R1_sq - R2_sq + d_len2) / (2*d_len)) radius_T_sq = sp.simplify(R1_sq - a2) radius_T = sp.simplify(sp.sqrt(radius_T_sq)) print("Circle T radius^2:", radius_T_sq) print("Circle T radius:", radius_T)

Now area of circle T: pi * r^2

area_T = sp.simplify(sp.pi * radius_T_sq) print("Area of T (circle itself):", area_T)

Now projection onto plane ABC.

Need unit normal n_ABC of plane ABC, and unit normal of circle's plane n_T (already computed as n_T).

n_ABC = (B-A).cross(C-A) print("n_ABC (unnormalized):", sp.simplify(n_ABC))

Area of orthogonal projection of a region in a plane with normal n_T onto a plane with normal n_ABC

is area * |cos(theta)| where theta is angle between normals: cos(theta) = (n_T·n_ABC)/(|n_T||n_ABC|)

nT = n_T nABC = n_ABC cos_theta = sp.simplify((nT.dot(nABC)) / (sp.sqrt(nT.dot(nT))*sp.sqrt(nABC.dot(nABC)))) scale = sp.simplify(abs(cos_theta)) print("cos(theta) (abs):", scale)

area_proj = sp.simplify(area_T * scale) print("Projected area:", area_proj)

Express area_proj as pi/k

k = sp.simplify(sp.pi / area_proj) print("k =", k.simplify())

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] dot products for perpendicularity (should be 0): 0 0 B: Matrix([[0], [2*sqrt(3)], [2]]) G: Matrix([[0], [2*sqrt(3)/3], [2]]) n_ACD (unnormalized): Matrix([[0], [-16], [0]]) Radius R of sphere S: 2*sqrt(3)/3 Sphere S equation (symbolic, =0): x**2 + y**2 - 4*sqrt(3)*y/3 + z**2 - 4*z + 4 Right angle condition (symbolic, =0): x**2 + y*(3*y - 2*sqrt(3))/3 + (z - 4)*(z - 2) Plane of circle T (equation =0): -2*sqrt(3)*y/3 + 2*z - 4 Plane circle simplified: -2*(sqrt(3)*y - 3*z + 6)/3 coefficients (pre-normalization): 0 -2*sqrt(3)/3 2 n_T: Matrix([[0], [-2*sqrt(3)/3], [2]]) d: -4 C2: Matrix([[0], [sqrt(3)/3], [3]]) r2^2: 4/3 t solution(s): [1/2] Center M of circle T: Matrix([[0], [sqrt(3)/2], [5/2]]) d_len between centers: 2*sqrt(3)/3 Circle T radius^2: 1 Circle T radius: 1 Area of T (circle itself): pi n_ABC (unnormalized): Matrix([[-8*sqrt(3)], [4], [4*sqrt(3)]]) cos(theta) (abs): 1/4 Projected area: pi/4 k = 4 [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] Using the verified Python computations, the projected area of locus T onto plane ABC is π/4, so k = 4. \boxed{4}

Final Model Output
4

Comparative Analysis (P47) (Average across runs)

Avg Time Taken

Deepseek-V3.2
1339.3
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
227.0
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
197.5
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
88.5
GPT-5.1 (high)
77.0
Claude-Opus-4.5
62.7
Grok-4.1-fast
45.4
A.X-4.0 (72B)
24.3
HCX-007(high)
13.4
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
6.9

Avg Token Usage

Deepseek-V3.2
168251.0
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
45158.0
Claude-Opus-4.5
22479.0
Grok-4.1-fast
12799.0
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
11892.0
GPT-5.1 (high)
9482.0
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
4517.0
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
3060.0
A.X-4.0 (72B)
2321.0
HCX-007(high)
1815.0