Problem Analysis #49

47.50s
8,154 toks
Problem Statement

In the coordinate plane, let ABAB be a segment of length 10$$\sqrt{2}$$$, and consider the circle with diameter AB.Points. Points PandandQlieonthiscircleandsatisfylie on this circle and satisfy(\overrightarrow{\text{PA}} + \overrightarrow{\text{PB}}) \cdot (\overrightarrow{\text{PQ}} + \overrightarrow{\text{PB}}) = 2\left|\overrightarrow{\text{PQ}}\right|^2.If. If \left|\overrightarrow{\text{PB}}\right| = 14andand\left|\overrightarrow{\text{QB}}\right| > 0,then, then \left|\overrightarrow{\text{PA}} \cdot \overrightarrow{\text{QB}}\right| = \dfrac{q}{p},where, where pandandqarecoprimenaturalnumbers.Computeare coprime natural numbers. Computep + q$. [4 points]

Ground Truth
221
Execution Trace
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] I'll set up symbolic coordinates for points A, B, P, Q, encode the circle constraints and the given vector/dot-product condition, then solve the resulting system with sympy. After obtaining all valid solutions, I'll compute the value(s) of |PA · QB| and identify the rational value q/p, then output p+q. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] from sympy import symbols, Eq, sqrt, solve, Matrix, simplify, nsimplify

Define symbols

px, py, qx, qy = symbols('px py qx qy', real=True) s2 = sqrt(2)

Constants and fixed points

A = Matrix([-5s2, 0]) B = Matrix([ 5s2, 0]) P = Matrix([px, py]) Q = Matrix([qx, qy])

Circle radius^2

r2 = (5*s2)**2 # should be 50

Vectors

PA = A - P PB = B - P PQ = Q - P QB = B - Q

Equations

eq_circle_P = Eq(px2 + py2, r2) eq_circle_Q = Eq(qx2 + qy2, r2) eq_PB_len = Eq((px-5*s2)2 + py2, 14**2)

lhs_vec = (PA + PB).dot(PQ + PB) rhs_vec = 2 * (PQ.dot(PQ)) eq_dot = Eq(lhs_vec, rhs_vec)

eq_circle_P, eq_circle_Q, eq_PB_len, eq_dot print(eq_circle_P) print(eq_circle_Q) print(eq_PB_len) print(eq_dot)

Solve system

solutions = solve([eq_circle_P, eq_circle_Q, eq_PB_len, eq_dot], [px, py, qx, qy], dict=True)

len(solutions)[THOUGHT] I need to see the solutions from Python to determine |PA · QB| and then express it as q/p. [/THOUGHT]

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] SyntaxError: invalid character '·' (U+00B7) (<string>, line 43) [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] The previous code failed due to a Unicode middle-dot character inside a comment. I'll rewrite the code without any such characters, re-solve the system, then compute |PA · QB| from the valid solution(s). Finally I'll convert that value to q/p and compute p+q. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] from sympy import symbols, Eq, sqrt, solve, Matrix, simplify, nsimplify, Rational

Define symbols

px, py, qx, qy = symbols('px py qx qy', real=True) s2 = sqrt(2)

Fixed points A, B (AB has length 10*sqrt(2))

A = Matrix([-5s2, 0]) B = Matrix([ 5s2, 0])

P = Matrix([px, py]) Q = Matrix([qx, qy])

Circle radius^2 (circle with diameter AB, center at origin)

r2 = (5*s2)**2 # should be 50

Vectors

PA = A - P PB = B - P PQ = Q - P QB = B - Q

Equations:

1) P on circle

eq_circle_P = Eq(px2 + py2, r2)

2) Q on circle

eq_circle_Q = Eq(qx2 + qy2, r2)

3) |PB| = 14

eq_PB_len = Eq((px-5*s2)2 + py2, 14**2)

4) (PA + PB) dot (PQ + PB) = 2|PQ|^2

lhs_vec = (PA + PB).dot(PQ + PB) rhs_vec = 2 * (PQ.dot(PQ)) eq_dot = Eq(lhs_vec, rhs_vec)

print(eq_circle_P) print(eq_circle_Q) print(eq_PB_len) print(eq_dot)

solutions = solve( [eq_circle_P, eq_circle_Q, eq_PB_len, eq_dot], [px, py, qx, qy], dict=True )

print("Number of solutions:", len(solutions)) for sol in solutions: print("Solution:", sol) # Reconstruct vectors for this solution P_sol = Matrix([sol[px], sol[py]]) Q_sol = Matrix([sol[qx], sol[qy]])

PA_sol = A - P_sol
QB_sol = B - Q_sol

dot_val = simplify(PA_sol.dot(QB_sol))
abs_dot = simplify(abs(dot_val))
print("PA·QB =", dot_val, " |PA·QB| =", abs_dot)

From the absolute dot values, identify the rational q/p and compute p+q

We'll collect distinct abs values and attempt nsimplify as a Rational.

abs_values = [] for sol in solutions: P_sol = Matrix([sol[px], sol[py]]) Q_sol = Matrix([sol[qx], sol[qy]]) PA_sol = A - P_sol QB_sol = B - Q_sol dot_val = simplify(PA_sol.dot(QB_sol)) abs_dot = simplify(abs(dot_val)) abs_values.append(abs_dot)

print("Absolute dot product values:", abs_values)

Simplify each to a rational if possible

rats = [] for v in abs_values: r = nsimplify(v, [sqrt(2)]) rats.append(r) print("nsimplify:", v, "->", r)

Assume all valid solutions give same |PA·QB|

if rats: r0 = rats[0] r0_qp = Rational(r0) p = r0_qp.q q = r0_qp.p print("Chosen |PA·QB| =", r0_qp, " = q/p with q =", q, "p =", p, "p+q =", p+q) [/PYTHON]

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] Eq(px**2 + py**2, 50) Eq(qx**2 + qy**2, 50) Eq(py**2 + (px - 5*sqrt(2))**2, 196) Eq(-2*px*(-2*px + qx + 5*sqrt(2)) - 2*py*(-2*py + qy), 2*(-px + qx)**2 + 2*(-py + qy)**2) Number of solutions: 4 Solution: {px: -24*sqrt(2)/5, py: -7*sqrt(2)/5, qx: 527*sqrt(2)/125, qy: 336*sqrt(2)/125} PA·QB = -196/25 |PA·QB| = 196/25 Solution: {px: -24*sqrt(2)/5, py: -7*sqrt(2)/5, qx: 5*sqrt(2), qy: 0} PA·QB = 0 |PA·QB| = 0 Solution: {px: -24*sqrt(2)/5, py: 7*sqrt(2)/5, qx: 527*sqrt(2)/125, qy: -336*sqrt(2)/125} PA·QB = -196/25 |PA·QB| = 196/25 Solution: {px: -24*sqrt(2)/5, py: 7*sqrt(2)/5, qx: 5*sqrt(2), qy: 0} PA·QB = 0 |PA·QB| = 0 Absolute dot product values: [196/25, 0, 196/25, 0] nsimplify: 196/25 -> 196/25 nsimplify: 0 -> 0 nsimplify: 196/25 -> 196/25 nsimplify: 0 -> 0 Chosen |PA·QB| = 196/25 = q/p with q = 196 p = 25 p+q = 221 [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] From the valid solutions with |QB|>0, we get (|\overrightarrow{PA}\cdot\overrightarrow{QB}| = \frac{196}{25}), so (q=196), (p=25), and (p+q=221). [ \boxed{221} ]

Final Model Output
221

Comparative Analysis (P49) (Average across runs)

Avg Time Taken

Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
294.2
Deepseek-V3.2
188.8
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
67.4
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
63.9
A.X-4.0 (72B)
54.9
GPT-5.1 (high)
47.5
HCX-007(high)
46.1
Grok-4.1-fast
39.0
Claude-Opus-4.5
24.8
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
7.2

Avg Token Usage

Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
11533.0
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
11196.0
Deepseek-V3.2
8281.0
GPT-5.1 (high)
8154.0
A.X-4.0 (72B)
7809.0
HCX-007(high)
7771.0
Grok-4.1-fast
7303.0
Claude-Opus-4.5
5627.0
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
4565.0
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
2427.0