Problem Analysis #9

139.82s
16,139 toks
Problem Statement

In the two-dimensional orthogonal xyxy coordinate system, consider the curve LL represented by the following equations with the parameter tt (0 $$\leq$$ t $$\leq$$ 2$$\pi$$$). Here, a$ is a positive real constant.\begin{align}x(t) &= a(t - \sin t), \\y(t) &= a(1 - \cos t).\end{align}

  • [(I-1)] Obtain the length of the curve LL when tt varies in the range $0 \leq t \leq 2$$\pi$$$.

  • [(I-2)] For 0 < t < 2$$\pi$$$, obtain the curvature \kappa_L(t)atanarbitrarypointofthecurveat an arbitrary point of the curveL.Inthethreedimensionalorthogonal. In the three-dimensional orthogonal xyzcoordinatesystem,considerthecurvedsurfacerepresentedbythefollowingequationswiththeparameterscoordinate system, consider the curved surface represented by the following equations with the parametersuandandv( (uandandv$ are real numbers):\begin{align}x(u, v) &= \sinh u \cos v, \\y(u, v) &= 2 \sinh u \sin v, \\z(u, v) &= 3 \cosh u.\end{align}

  • [(II-1)] Express the curved surface by an equation without the parameters uu and vv.

  • [(II-2)] Sketch the xyxy-plane view at z=5z = 5 and the xzxz-plane view at y=0y = 0, respectively, of the curved surface. In the sketches, indicate the values at the intersections with each of the axes.

  • [(II-3)] Express a unit normal vector n\mathbf{n} of the curved surface by uu and vv. Here, the zz-component of n\mathbf{n} should be positive.

  • [(II-4)] Let κ\kappa be the Gaussian curvature at the point u=v=0u = v = 0. Calculate the absolute value κ|\kappa|. Finally, define the following quantities:

  • Let LL be the length of the cycloid in {\rm (I-1)}, and let κL(π)\kappa_L(\pi) be the curvature of LL at t=πt = \pi from {\rm (I-2)}. Define α:=LκL(π). \alpha := L \cdot \kappa_L(\pi).

  • In {\rm (II-2)}, denote by Ax>0A_x > 0 and Ay>0A_y > 0 the xx- and yy-intercepts (respectively) of the cross-section of the surface by the plane z=5z = 5, and by Az>0A_z > 0 the zz-intercept of the cross-section by the plane y=0y = 0. Define δ:=AxAyAz,ρ:=AyAx. \delta := A_x A_y A_z, \qquad \rho := \frac{A_y}{A_x}.

  • In {\rm (II-4)}, let β:=κ\beta := |\kappa| be the absolute value of the Gaussian curvature at u=v=0u = v = 0. Using these, defineS:=(αβδρ)3,K:=999S2+7.S := \bigl(\alpha\,\beta\,\delta\,\rho\bigr)^3,\qquad\mathcal{K} := 999\,S^2 + 7.Compute the integer K\mathcal{K}.\

Ground Truth
781975031906311
Execution Trace
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] I will symbolically compute all needed quantities (α, β, δ, ρ) using Python and Sympy, then form S and 𝓚, and simplify exactly as rationals to get an integer result. [/THOUGHT] [PYTHON] import sympy as sp

Part I: Cycloid quantities

t, a = sp.symbols('t a', positive=True, real=True)

x = a*(t - sp.sin(t)) y = a*(1 - sp.cos(t))

dx = sp.diff(x, t) dy = sp.diff(y, t) ddx = sp.diff(dx, t) ddy = sp.diff(dy, t)

Speed and length L from t=0 to 2π

speed = sp.sqrt(dx2 + dy2) L = sp.simplify(sp.integrate(speed, (t, 0, 2*sp.pi)))

Curvature κ_L(t) = |x'y'' - y'x''| / ( (x'^2 + y'^2)^(3/2) )

numerator = sp.simplify(dxddy - dyddx) denominator = sp.simplify((dx2 + dy2)**sp.Rational(3,2)) kappa_t = sp.simplify(sp.Abs(numerator) / denominator)

Evaluate curvature at t = π (0 < π < 2π, so signs are clear)

kappa_pi = sp.simplify(kappa_t.subs(t, sp.pi))

alpha = L * κ_L(π)

alpha = sp.simplify(L * kappa_pi)

print("L =", L) print("kappa(t) =", kappa_t) print("kappa(pi) =", kappa_pi) print("alpha =", alpha)

Part II: Surface quantities via implicit form and cross-sections

u, v = sp.symbols('u v', real=True)

x_uv = sp.sinh(u)sp.cos(v) y_uv = 2sp.sinh(u)sp.sin(v) z_uv = 3sp.cosh(u)

Derive implicit equation: eliminate u,v

From parameterization we know: x^2 + (y^2)/4 = sinh^2(u)

and z = 3 cosh(u) => sinh^2(u) = cosh(u)**2 - 1 = (z^2/9) - 1

z = sp.symbols('z', real=True) implicit_eq = sp.Eq(x2 + y2/4, z**2/9 - 1) # as symbolic equation

Rearrange to standard form:

implicit_simplified = sp.simplify((x2 + y2/4) - (z**2/9 - 1))

print("Implicit equation (zero form) =", implicit_simplified)

Cross-section at z = 5: x^2 + y^2/4 = (z^2 - 9)/9

z_val = 5 rhs_ellipse = (z_val**2 - 9)/9 # = 16/9 Ax = sp.sqrt(rhs_ellipse) # when y=0 Ay = sp.sqrt(4rhs_ellipse) # when x=0, y^2/4 = rhs => y^2 = 4rhs Ax_simplified = sp.simplify(Ax) Ay_simplified = sp.simplify(Ay)

print("Ax =", Ax_simplified) print("Ay =", Ay_simplified)

Cross-section at y = 0:

From implicit: 9x^2 + (9/4)y^2 = z**2 - 9

Set y=0 => 9x^2 = z**2 - 9 => z^2 = 9x^2 + 9

x_sym = sp.symbols('x_sym', real=True) z_curve = sp.sqrt(9*x_sym**2 + 9) # positive branch since z>=3 Az = sp.simplify(z_curve.subs(x_sym, 0)) # z-intercept print("Az =", Az)

delta = sp.simplify(Ax_simplified * Ay_simplified * Az) rho = sp.simplify(Ay_simplified / Ax_simplified)

print("delta =", delta) print("rho =", rho)

Part II-4: Gaussian curvature β at (u,v) = (0,0)

x_u = sp.diff(x_uv, u) x_v = sp.diff(x_uv, v) y_u = sp.diff(y_uv, u) y_v = sp.diff(y_uv, v) z_u = sp.diff(z_uv, u) z_v = sp.diff(z_uv, v)

r_u = sp.Matrix([x_u, y_u, z_u]) r_v = sp.Matrix([x_v, y_v, z_v])

First fundamental form coefficients

E = sp.simplify(r_u.dot(r_u)) F = sp.simplify(r_u.dot(r_v)) G = sp.simplify(r_v.dot(r_v))

Unit normal n = (r_u × r_v)/|r_u × r_v|

r_u_cross_r_v = sp.simplify(r_u.cross(r_v)) norm_cross = sp.sqrt(r_u_cross_r_v.dot(r_u_cross_r_v)) n_vec = sp.simplify(r_u_cross_r_v / norm_cross)

print("r_u × r_v =", r_u_cross_r_v) print("Unit normal n(u,v) =", n_vec)

Second derivatives

x_uu = sp.diff(x_u, u) x_uv = sp.diff(x_u, v) x_vv = sp.diff(x_v, v)

y_uu = sp.diff(y_u, u) y_uv = sp.diff(y_u, v) y_vv = sp.diff(y_v, v)

z_uu = sp.diff(z_u, u) z_uv = sp.diff(z_u, v) z_vv = sp.diff(z_v, v)

r_uu = sp.Matrix([x_uu, y_uu, z_uu]) r_uv = sp.Matrix([x_uv, y_uv, z_uv]) r_vv = sp.Matrix([x_vv, y_vv, z_vv])

Second fundamental form coefficients

e = sp.simplify(n_vec.dot(r_uu)) f = sp.simplify(n_vec.dot(r_uv)) g = sp.simplify(n_vec.dot(r_vv))

print("E =", E) print("F =", F) print("G =", G) print("e =", e) print("f =", f) print("g =", g)

Gaussian curvature K = (eg - f^2) / (EG - F^2)

K_uv = sp.simplify((eg - f**2) / (EG - F**2))

Evaluate at u=0, v=0

K_00 = sp.simplify(K_uv.subs({u:0, v:0})) beta = sp.simplify(sp.Abs(K_00))

print("Gaussian curvature K(u,v) =", K_uv) print("K(0,0) =", K_00) print("beta =", beta)

Final S and K calculation

S = sp.simplify((alpha * beta * delta * rho)3) K_final = sp.simplify(999 * S2 + 7)

print("S =", S) print("K_final =", K_final)

Tool Output
[PYTHON OUTPUT] L = sqrt(2)*a*Integral(sqrt(1 - cos(t)), (t, 0, 2*pi)) kappa(t) = sqrt(2)*Abs(cos(t) - 1)/(4*a*(1 - cos(t))**(3/2)) kappa(pi) = 1/(4*a) alpha = sqrt(2)*Integral(sqrt(1 - cos(t)), (t, 0, 2*pi))/4 Implicit equation (zero form) = a**2*(t - sin(t))**2 + a**2*(cos(t) - 1)**2/4 - z**2/9 + 1 Ax = 1.33333333333333 Ay = 2.66666666666667 Az = 3 delta = 10.6666666666667 rho = 2.00000000000000 r_u × r_v = Matrix([[-6*cos(v)*sinh(u)**2], [-3*sin(v)*sinh(u)**2], [sinh(2*u)]]) Unit normal n(u,v) = Matrix([[-6*cos(v)*sinh(u)**2/(sqrt(-27*sin(v)**2*sinh(u)**2 + 40*sinh(u)**2 + 4)*Abs(sinh(u)))], [-3*sin(v)*sinh(u)**2/(sqrt(-27*sin(v)**2*sinh(u)**2 + 40*sinh(u)**2 + 4)*Abs(sinh(u)))], [sinh(2*u)/(sqrt(-27*sin(v)**2*sinh(u)**2 + 40*sinh(u)**2 + 4)*Abs(sinh(u)))]]) E = 3*sin(v)**2*cosh(u)**2 + 10*cosh(u)**2 - 9 F = 3*sin(2*v)*sinh(2*u)/4 G = -(3*sin(v)**2 - 4)*sinh(u)**2 e = 6*sinh(u)/(sqrt(-27*sin(v)**2*sinh(u)**2 + 40*sinh(u)**2 + 4)*Abs(sinh(u))) f = 0 g = 6*sinh(u)**3/(sqrt(-27*sin(v)**2*sinh(u)**2 + 40*sinh(u)**2 + 4)*Abs(sinh(u))) Gaussian curvature K(u,v) = -576*sinh(u)**2/(((48*sin(v)**2 - 64)*(3*sin(v)**2*cosh(u)**2 + 10*cosh(u)**2 - 9)*sinh(u)**2 + 9*sin(2*v)**2*sinh(2*u)**2)*(-27*sin(v)**2*sinh(u)**2 + 40*sinh(u)**2 + 4)) K(0,0) = nan beta = nan S = nan K_final = nan [/PYTHON OUTPUT]
Reasoning Process

[THOUGHT] Using the geometric and differential-geometric analysis (with the earlier Python outputs as guidance), we obtain:

  • Cycloid length (L = 8a),
  • Curvature at (t=\pi): (\kappa_L(\pi)=\frac{1}{4a}),
  • Hence (\alpha = L\kappa_L(\pi)=2).

For the surface:

  • Implicit equation: (x^2 + \frac{y^2}{4} = \frac{z^2}{9} - 1).
  • Cross-section at (z=5): ellipse (x^2 + \frac{y^2}{4} = \frac{16}{9}), so (A_x=\frac{4}{3},\ A_y=\frac{8}{3}).
  • Cross-section at (y=0): (z^2 = 9x^2+9), so (A_z=3). Thus (\delta = A_xA_yA_z = \frac{32}{3},\ \rho=\frac{A_y}{A_x}=2).

At the point ((u,v)=(0,0)), corresponding to ((x,y,z)=(0,0,3)), viewing the surface as the graph (z = f(x,y) = \sqrt{9x^2 + \tfrac{9}{4}y^2 + 9}), the Gaussian curvature via (K = \dfrac{f_{xx}f_{yy}-f_{xy}^2}{(1+f_x^2+f_y^2)^2}) at ((0,0)) is (\kappa = \frac{9}{4}), so (\beta = |\kappa| = \frac{9}{4}).

Therefore, [ \alpha\beta\delta\rho = 2 \cdot \frac{9}{4} \cdot \frac{32}{3} \cdot 2 = 96, ] so [ S = (96)^3 = 884736,\quad S^2 = 782757789696, ] and [ \mathcal{K} = 999S^2 + 7 = 781975031906311. ] [/THOUGHT] \boxed{781975031906311}

Final Model Output
781975031906311

Comparative Analysis (P9) (Average across runs)

Avg Time Taken

A.X-4.0 (72B)
1385.0
Deepseek-V3.2
484.2
Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
298.7
GPT-5.1 (high)
139.8
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
134.8
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
94.3
Grok-4.1-fast
79.4
HCX-007(high)
44.1
Claude-Opus-4.5
37.4
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
33.3

Avg Token Usage

Solar-Pro-2 (31B)(high)
23128.0
GPT-5.1 (high)
16139.0
Deepseek-V3.2
14111.0
Grok-4.1-fast
13877.0
Gemini-3-Pro-Preview
13470.0
Llama-VARCO-8B-Instruct
8865.0
Claude-Opus-4.5
8603.0
A.X-4.0 (72B)
7948.0
EXAONE-4.0.1-32B (high)
6907.0
HCX-007(high)
6048.0