Problem Analysis #21

DeepSeek V4 Pro · Run 1

Correct
98.04s
5,622 toks

API · no tools. This is the prompt and response recorded for this attempt; a full solution may not have been returned.

Problem Statement

Return a single integer only. The problem has been revised so that no final answer is an irrational number, a parameterized expression, a range, a proof, a drawing, a graph, a locus equation, or a region description.

From the 1515 lattice points

{(x,y):x,yZ, 1x3,1y5},\{(x,y):x,y\in\mathbb Z,\ 1\le x\le3, 1\le y\le5\},

choose three distinct points uniformly at random. Let p5p_5 be the probability that the three chosen points are the vertices of a triangle. If p5=p/qp_5=p/q in lowest terms, find p+qp+q.

Ground Truth
867
Recorded model response / solution
Reasoning Process

The total number of lattice points is 1515. Choosing 3 points gives (153)=455\binom{15}{3} = 455 total triplets. A triangle is formed if the three points are not collinear.

Collinear triplets occur on:

  • Horizontal lines: 5 lines, each with 3 points → 5 triplets.
  • Vertical lines: 3 lines, each with 5 points → 3×(53)=303 \times \binom{5}{3} = 30 triplets.
  • Diagonal lines: any non-vertical, non-horizontal collinear triplet must have xx-coordinates 1,2,31,2,3; the yy-coordinates form an arithmetic progression with difference dd such that all yy values lie in 1,,51,\dots,5.
    • d=1d=1: y=1,2,3y=1,2,3; 2,3,42,3,4; 3,4,53,4,5 → 3 lines.
    • d=1d=-1: y=5,4,3y=5,4,3; 4,3,24,3,2; 3,2,13,2,1 → 3 lines.
    • d=2d=2: y=1,3,5y=1,3,5 → 1 line.
    • d=2d=-2: y=5,3,1y=5,3,1 → 1 line.
      Total diagonal triplets = 8.

Total collinear triplets = 5+30+8=435 + 30 + 8 = 43.
Probability of a triangle = 143455=4124551 - \frac{43}{455} = \frac{412}{455}.
Since 412412 and 455455 are coprime, p=412p=412, q=455q=455, and p+q=867p+q=867.

\boxed{867}

Final Model Output
867

Comparative Analysis (P21) (Average across runs)

Averages use reported measurements only. Missing usage is not treated as zero.

Avg Time Taken

K-EXAONE-236B-A23B
122.0
DeepSeek V4 Pro
93.8
Solar Pro 3
61.7
Gemini 3.5 Flash
19.0
Claude Opus 4.8
14.5
GPT-5.5
13.5
KT Mi:dm 2.0 Base Instruct
2.7

Avg Token Usage

K-EXAONE-236B-A23B
17431.0
Solar Pro 3
9212.3
DeepSeek V4 Pro
5621.7
Gemini 3.5 Flash
4505.0
KT Mi:dm 2.0 Base Instruct
1601.7
Claude Opus 4.8
1420.7
GPT-5.5
714.7
    Tokyo · Problem 21 · DeepSeek V4 Pro | EntropyMath