Problem Analysis #common_06

Union Alpha · Run 1

Python ● execution succeeded
Correct
87.62s
5,169 toks

부분 결과 · 오류와 사용량 확인 보류는 채점에서 제외합니다. 오류·답 추출 실패 재시도 기록을 포함하며 원본은 보존했습니다. Python 실행 성공은 수학적 증명 검증을 뜻하지 않습니다.

Problem Statement

1보다 큰 두 실수 a,ba,b가 log⁡ab=3\log_a b=3, log⁡3ba=12\log_3\frac ba=\frac12를 만족시킬 때, log⁡9(ab)\log_9(ab)의 값은?

① 38\frac38 ② 12\frac12 ③ 58\frac58 ④ 34\frac34 ⑤ 78\frac78

최종 답은 선택지 번호 1~5 중 하나를 \boxed{} 안에 쓰세요.

Ground Truth
2
Recorded model response / solution
Reasoning Process

Recorded Python call:

{}
Tool Output
Execution failed invalid python arguments
Reasoning Process

Recorded Python call:

from fractions import Fraction
from sympy import symbols, log, Rational, solveset, S, Eq

# a, b > 1 with log_a b = 3  ->  b = a^3
# log_3 (b/a) = 1/2        ->  b/a = 3^(1/2)
a = symbols('a', positive=True)
b = a**3
# condition: b/a = sqrt(3)  => a^2 = sqrt(3) => a = 3^(1/4)
sol = solveset(Eq(a**2, 3**Rational(1,2)), a, domain=S.Reals)
print("candidate a:", sol)
a_val = list(sol)[0]
b_val = a_val**3
print("check a>1,b>1:", a_val > 1, b_val > 1)
print("check log_a b = 3:", log(b_val, a_val).simplify())
print("check log_3(b/a) = 1/2:", log(b_val/a_val, 3).simplify())
ab = a_val * b_val          # = a^4 = 3
print("ab simplifies to:", ab.simplify(), "== 3:", ab == 3)
print("log_9(ab) =", log(ab, 9).simplify())
print("as fraction:", Fraction(1,2))
Tool Output
Execution succeeded candidate a: {-3**(1/4), 3**(1/4)} check a>1,b>1: True True check log_a b = 3: 3 check log_3(b/a) = 1/2: 1/2 ab simplifies to: 3 == 3: True log_9(ab) = 1/2 as fraction: 1/2
Reasoning Process

풀이 (계산으로 확인):

  • log⁡ab=3⇒b=a3\log_a b = 3 \Rightarrow b = a^3 (a,b>1)
  • log⁡3ba=12⇒ba=31/2\log_3 \frac ba = \frac12 \Rightarrow \frac ba = 3^{1/2}

두 식을 결합하면 b/a=a2=31/2b/a = a^2 = 3^{1/2}이므로 a=31/4a = 3^{1/4}, b=33/4b = 3^{3/4} (둘 다 1보다 큼, 위 실행에서 조건 log⁡ab=3\log_a b=3, log⁡3(b/a)=12\log_3(b/a)=\frac12 만족 확인).

따라서 ab=31/4⋅33/4=3ab = 3^{1/4}\cdot 3^{3/4} = 3이고,

log⁡9(ab)=log⁡93=12\log_9(ab) = \log_9 3 = \frac12

Python 심볼릭 계산에서도 log⁡9(ab)=1/2\log_9(ab) = 1/2가 확인되었습니다. 이는 선택지 ②에 해당합니다.

Reasoning Process

Recorded Python call:

from sympy import Rational
print("choice 2 corresponds to:", Rational(1,2))
Tool Output
Execution succeeded choice 2 corresponds to: 1/2
Reasoning Process

2\boxed{2}

Final Model Output
2

Comparative Analysis (Pcommon_06) (Average across runs)

Averages use reported measurements only. Missing usage is not treated as zero.

Avg Time Taken

Union Alpha
87.6
Motif 3
59.6
Grok 4.7
38.9
MiMo V2.6 Pro
19.9
Muse Spark 1.3
11.5
Solar Pro 4
8.7
DeepSeek V4.1 Flash
4.2
Solar Mini 4 Preview
3.4

Avg Token Usage

Muse Spark 1.3
6,137
Grok 4.7
6,067
Union Alpha
5,169
Motif 3
4,942
MiMo V2.6 Pro
2,646
DeepSeek V4.1 Flash
2,595
Solar Mini 4 Preview
2,496
Solar Pro 4
1,372
    CSAT 2026 · Problem common_06 · Union Alpha | EntropyMath